Hokie ClubAthletic All-Americans
| Year | Name | Team | Pos. |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2006 | Angela Tincher | 2nd | Pitcher |
| 2007 | Angela Tincher | 1st | Pitcher |
| 2008 | Angela Tincher | 1st | Pitcher |
| 2009 | Jenna Rhodes | 3rd | At-Large Outfield |
| 2021 | Keely Rochard | 1st | Pitcher |
| 2022 | Emma Ritter | 3rd (NFCA) | Outfielder |
| 2022 | Keely Rochard | 1st (NFCA) | Pitcher |
| 2024 | Michelle Chatfield | Freshman (Softball America), All-Freshman (D1 Softball) | Infielder |
| 2024 | Addy Greene | 1st (NFCA) | Outfielder |
| 2024 | Cori McMillan | 2nd (NFCA), 2nd (Softball America) | Outfielder |
| 2024 | Emma Ritter | 1st (NFCA), 1st (D1 Softball) |
Academic All-Americans
As selected by CoSIDA
| Year | Name | Team | Pos. |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1998 | Michelle Johnson | 3rd | P |
| 1998 | Michelle Meadows | 2nd | 2B |
| 1999 | Michelle Meadows | 1st | 2B |
| 2000 | Michelle Meadows | 1st | 2B |
| 2002 | Ashlee Dobbe | 1st | P |
| 2006 | Angela Tincher | 2nd | P |
| 2007 | Angela Tincher | 1st | P |
| 2008 | Angela Tincher Y | 1st | P |
| 2009 | Jenna Rhodes | 2nd | OF |
U - Unanimous Selection
C - Consensus Selection
Y - Academic All-American of the Year