Hokie Club| Year | Bracket | Opponent | Score | Date | Location | Coach |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2005 | Regional (#11 Tennessee) |
#3 College of Charleston | L, 2-10 (6) | May 20 | Knoxville, Tenn. | Scot Thomas |
| #4 Miami University | W, 4-1 | May 21 | ||||
| #3 College of Charleston | L, 3-6 | |||||
| 2006 | Regional (#8 Tennessee) |
#2 Louisville | W, 1-0 (12) | May 19 | Knoxville, Tenn. | Scot Thomas |
| #1 Tennessee | L, 1-9 (5) | May 20 | ||||
| #2 Louisville | L, 1-10 (5) | |||||
| 2007 | Regional (#16 Virginia Tech) |
#4 Canisius | W, 5-0 | May 18 | Columbus, Ohio | Scot Thomas |
| #2 Ohio State | L, 1-2 | May 19 | ||||
| #3 Cal State Fullerton | L, 0-1 | |||||
| 2008 | Regional (#13 Tennessee) |
#3 Louisville | W, 1-0 | May 16 | Knoxville, Tenn. | Scot Thomas |
| #1 Tennessee | W, 4-0 | May 17 | ||||
| #1 Tennessee | L, 1-7 | May 18 | ||||
| #1 Tennessee | W, 4-2 | |||||
| Super Regional (#4 Michigan) |
#4 Michigan | L, 0-1 | May 24 | Ann Arbor, Mich. | ||
| #4 Michigan | W, 1-0 | May 25 | ||||
| #4 Michigan | W, 6-1 | |||||
| WCWS | #5 Texas A&M | L, 0-1 | May 29 | Oklahoma City, Okla. | ||
| #1 Florida | L, 0-2 (9) | May 31 | ||||
| 2012 | Regional (#7 Tennessee) |
#2 UAB | W, 4-1 | May 20 | Knoxville, Tenn. | Scot Thomas |
| #4 Miami University | W, 6-0 | May 21 | ||||
| #1 Tennessee | L, 1-2 | May 22 | ||||
| #1 Tennessee | L, 2-10 | |||||
| 2013 | Regional (#12 Kentucky) |
#3 Notre Dame | W, 4-3 | May 17 | Lexington, Ky. | Scot Thomas |
| #1 Kentucky | L, 2-6 | May 18 | ||||
| #4 Marshall | W, 3-12 (13) | |||||
| #1 Kentucky | W, 2-0 | May 19 | ||||
| #1 Kentucky | L, 0-1 | |||||
| 2014 | Regional (#10 Tennessee) |
#2 Lipscomb | W, 4-3 | May 16 | Knoxville, Tenn. | Scot Thomas |
| #1 Tennessee | L, 0-12 (5) | May 17 | ||||
| #2 Lipscomb | L, 3-12 | |||||
| 2015 | Regional (#8 Tennessee) |
#3 Utah | L, 1-6 | May 20 | Knoxville, Tenn. | Scot Thomas |
| #4 Longwood | L, 4-6 (8) | May 21 | ||||
| 2019 | Regional (#14 Kentucky) |
#3 Illinois | W, 6-2 | May 17 | Lexington, Ky. | Pete D'Amour |
| #1 Kentucky | L, 1-8 | May 18 | ||||
| #3 Illinois | W, 5-1 | |||||
| #1 Kentucky | L, 1-11 (6) | May 19 | ||||
| 2021 | Regional (#15 Arizona State) |
#3 BYU | W, 5-2 | May 20 | Tempe, Ariz. | Pete D'Amour |
| #1 Arizona State | W, 8-2 | May 21 | ||||
| #3 BYU | W, 11-3 (5) | May 22 | ||||
| Super Regional (#2 UCLA) |
#2 UCLA | W, 7-2 | May 27 | Los Angeles, Calif. | ||
| #2 UCLA | L, 0-2 | May 28 | ||||
| #2 UCLA | L, 0-6 | May 29 | ||||
| 2022 | Regional (#3 Virginia Tech) |
#4 Saint Francis (PA) | W, 4-0 | May 20 | Blacksburg, Va. | Pete D'Amour |
| #2 Kentucky | L, 4-5 | May 21 | ||||
| #3 Miami (Ohio) | W, 5-4 | May 21 | ||||
| #2 Kentucky | W, 9-2 | May 22 | ||||
| #2 Kentucky | W, 5-4 | |||||
| Super Regional (#3 Virginia Tech) |
#14 Florida | W, 6-0 | May 27 | |||
| #14 Florida | L, 2-7 | May 28 | ||||
| #14 Florida | L, 0-12 (5) | May 29 | ||||
| 2023 | Regional (#14 Georgia) |
#3 Boston U | W, 6-1 | May 19 | Athens, Ga. | Pete D'Amour |
| #1 Georgia | L, 3-8 | May 20 | ||||
| #3 Boston U | W, 9-0 (5) | May 20 | ||||
| #1 Georgia | L, 3-12 (6) | May 21 | ||||
| 2024 | Regional (#6 UCLA) |
#3 San Diego State | May 17 | Los Angeles, Calif. | Pete D'Amour | |
| #1 UCLA/#4 Grand Ganyon | May 18 | Los Angeles, Calif. | ||||
| TOTAL | 27-29 (48.2) | |||||